Sherlock Holmes: The Devil's Daughter

Sherlock Holmes: The Devil's Daughter

Xbox One · 2016

Buy on eBay Buy on Amazon

About this game

In Sherlock Holmes: The Devil's Daughter , the player controls the fictional detective Sherlock Holmes.

The game is set in late 19th century London.

↓ Read more

Holmes have been completely redesigned to look younger and more dynamic, the game is still set in the same timeline as the rest of Frogware's Sherlock Holmes games.

While the four big cases are unrelated to each other, there is a framing story in which the detective has to deal with his adoptive daughter Kate (continuing the story of The Testament of Sherlock Holmes ) and a mysterious new neighbor.

The gameplay mechanics are mostly identical to the direct predecessor Crimes & Punishments: Sherlock Holmes : the player searches the environment for clues, interrogates suspects, solves mini games and makes deductions based on the found clues.

While inspecting persons, Holmes now sometimes has to choose between two alternative interpretations, e.g. if a red stain on the suit is wine or blood.

If the wrong alternative is chosen, it can't be taken back.

While this does not tamper the ability to solve the case, the person's character interpretation in the log is marked as incomplete.

The major difference in comparison to Crimes & Punishments is that the investigating and interrogating parts have been scaled back in favor of the mini-games.

While there are still many mini-games which can be solved quickly (e.g. using the lab to examine a piece of evidence, balancing or quick-time events), many are more involved: they are either action-based (e.g.

Holmes needs to flee from an assailant while frequently taking cover) or large-scale logic puzzles.

While the latter were always an integral part of the series, they were mostly gone from the direct predecessor.

Most mini-games can be skipped.

Additionally there are multiple occasions where player control shifts to another character.

Mostly it's just switching to Dr.

Watson during a puzzle sequence, but sometimes there are longer parts like a stealth sequenc

Data by MobyGames.com

About Xbox One

Microsoft's Xbox One launched in 2013 alongside the PS4 and leaned heavily into backwards compatibility and subscription services like Game Pass. Because so many Xbox One owners moved to all-digital libraries, physical Xbox One cartridges — sorry, discs — in good condition are comparatively less common on the secondhand market than their PlayStation equivalents from the same era.

Gamevaro tracks Sherlock Holmes: The Devil's Daughter for Xbox One with separate market values for loose, complete-in-box (CIB) and factory-sealed copies, sourced from real eBay sales. Prices also vary by region — PAL, NTSC-U and NTSC-J releases of the same game often sell for different amounts due to print run sizes and regional collector demand.

Adding Sherlock Holmes: The Devil's Daughter to a Gamevaro collection takes seconds — search by title or scan the box barcode, and the app fills in cover art, release details and current pricing automatically. This XONE release dates back to 2016.

Price history

PAL · Item only
€19.99
+€9.52
▲ 90.9%
€9.5 €13 €17 €21 05-1706-0806-2507-1007-12

Market values by condition

PAL

Box Only
€4.46
+ Add
Item only
€19.99
+ Add
Complete in Box
€11.16
+ Add
New (sealed)
€16.74
+ Add
Graded New
€18.41
+ Add

NTSC-U

Box Only
€5.42
+ Add
Item only
€24.55
+ Add
Complete in Box
€13.56
+ Add
New (sealed)
€31.13
+ Add
Graded New
€78.74
+ Add

Recent sales

DateTypeRegionPriceSource
2026-07-12 Box Only PAL €4.46 pricecharting
2026-07-12 Item only PAL €10.64 pricecharting
2026-07-12 Box Only NTSC-U €5.42 pricecharting
2026-07-12 New (sealed) PAL €16.74 pricecharting
2026-07-12 Complete in Box PAL €11.16 pricecharting
2026-07-12 Graded New NTSC-U €78.74 pricecharting
2026-07-12 Item only NTSC-U €13.11 pricecharting
2026-07-12 Graded New PAL €18.41 pricecharting
2026-07-12 Complete in Box NTSC-U €13.56 pricecharting
2026-07-12 New (sealed) NTSC-U €31.13 pricecharting
2026-07-10 Box Only PAL €4.46 pricecharting
2026-07-10 Graded New NTSC-U €78.71 pricecharting
2026-07-10 Item only PAL €10.63 pricecharting
2026-07-10 New (sealed) PAL €16.73 pricecharting
2026-07-10 Complete in Box PAL €11.16 pricecharting
2026-07-10 Complete in Box NTSC-U €13.55 pricecharting
2026-07-10 Box Only NTSC-U €5.42 pricecharting
2026-07-10 Item only NTSC-U €13.11 pricecharting
2026-07-10 Graded New PAL €18.40 pricecharting
2026-07-10 New (sealed) NTSC-U €31.11 pricecharting
2026-06-25 Item only NTSC-U €24.55 eBay US
2026-06-25 Item only PAL €19.99 eBay NL
2026-06-18 New (sealed) PAL €16.50 pricecharting
2026-06-18 New (sealed) NTSC-U €30.35 pricecharting
2026-06-18 Box Only PAL €4.40 pricecharting
2026-06-18 Graded New PAL €18.15 pricecharting
2026-06-18 Complete in Box PAL €11.00 pricecharting
2026-06-18 Complete in Box NTSC-U €13.80 pricecharting
2026-06-18 Item only NTSC-U €13.16 pricecharting
2026-06-18 Item only PAL €10.48 pricecharting

Market insights

🌍
PAL is 23% cheaper
The PAL version (€19.99) is significantly cheaper than NTSC-U (€24.55) loose. CIB: PAL €11.16, NTSC-U €13.56.
💡
Below average — potentially a good time to buy
Current price €10.64 is below the average of €12.13 over the tracked period (range: €10.47€19.99).

Rarity & condition

Sherlock Holmes: The Devil's Daughter has a steady sales history on the tracked marketplaces, meaning enough copies circulate to establish a reliable market price.

Complete-in-box (CIB) copies typically command a premium over loose cartridges/discs because the original box and manual are more fragile and get discarded or damaged over time — fewer complete sets survive.

Frequently asked questions

How much is Sherlock Holmes: The Devil's Daughter worth?

Sherlock Holmes: The Devil's Daughter for Xbox One is currently worth €19.99 loose, €11.16 complete in box, and €16.74 factory sealed. Prices are based on real sales and update regularly on Gamevaro.

Is Sherlock Holmes: The Devil's Daughter rare?

Sherlock Holmes: The Devil's Daughter has a steady sales history on the tracked marketplaces, meaning it trades hands regularly and isn't considered particularly rare.

What's the difference between loose, CIB and sealed for Sherlock Holmes: The Devil's Daughter?

Loose means cartridge or disc only, CIB (complete in box) includes the original box and manual, and sealed means factory-sealed and never opened. For Sherlock Holmes: The Devil's Daughter, loose is €19.99 and CIB is €11.16 — CIB commands a premium because original boxes and manuals are fragile and often don't survive.

Is Sherlock Holmes: The Devil's Daughter worth more in PAL or NTSC?

The PAL version of Sherlock Holmes: The Devil's Daughter is currently worth €19.99 loose, versus €24.55 for NTSC-U. Regional price differences usually come down to print run size and regional collector demand.

Ratings & Reviews

No ratings yet. Be the first!
Rate this game
★★★★★
Sign in to rate

Also on other platforms

More Xbox One games

Best Time to Buy

📊Average price period. Best historically: May
J
F
M
A
M
J
J
A
S
O
N
D
Based on 92 price records over 2 years · avg €21.86

💬 Community Discussions

+ Discuss
No threads about this game yet. Be the first!